Margin Call

Banks know the formula by heart: "Know Your Customer," the obligation to verify who opens an account before letting them act. On 22 October, in the Financial Times, John Thornhill, a columnist at the paper, proposes extending it to AI agents: "Know Your Agent." He wants it to be possible to control agents, and to know who answers for their actions.

Edition #28 · Margin Call

The same week, Salesforce, the vendor of the customer relationship tool that runs L'Oréal's consumer care service in North America, made identifying agents a basis for billing. Starting in November, it will require every agent outside its tool (a commercially available assistant, or an agent a brand has built itself) to be registered, then it will bill each action of that agent, according to The Information, an American site of investigative reporting on technology companies. At Salesforce, you will therefore pay for your own agents to read your own data: this is the agents' double bill.

The brand pays the provider of the AI model that runs its agent, then the vendor whose data that agent reads. The vendor then decides which of the brand's agents enter its tool and what each one pays: the brand no longer decides alone what its agents do with its VICs' records.

In Edition 17, a brand's dependence came from the provider of the AI model. This time, it comes from the vendor that hosts its data.

Cover: Jeremy Irons in "Margin Call," J. C. Chandor, 2011.

The film by J. C. Chandor follows over 24 hours the executives of a New York investment bank at the start of the 2008 financial crisis. It is clearly inspired by the fall of Lehman Brothers and the subprime crisis; Jeremy Irons, on the cover, plays John Tuld, the bank's Machiavellian CEO.

"Margin Call" is the bank's demand that its client pay in more money, or see its position closed. The title describes what is happening to brands. Salesforce and ServiceNow are about to make them the same call: for their agents to keep reading data that already belongs to them, they will have to pay more, or those agents will no longer be able to act in the tool. SAP, for its part, already counts every use, with no price announced.

Welcome to LUXE ÆTERNAI, my weekly decoding of what AI agents change, or don't, for Luxury Maisons. I am Michaël Tsakiris. I help leaders and their teams choose what they entrust to AI, put it in place, and I train them. Enjoy!

LUXE ÆTERNAI comes out every Thursday at 8:30am, on LinkedIn. Subscribe on LinkedIn

TL;DR (Too Long; Didn't Read)

The essentials of the week

The thesis. Salesforce announces that it will bill the actions of agents outside its customer relationship tool, after ServiceNow in May; SAP already counts every use, with no price announced. At Salesforce and ServiceNow, the brand will pay for its own agents to read its own data: this is the agents' double bill. For a brand with 200 boutiques whose agents prepare VIC appointments, my calculation comes to between $0.6 million and $1.8 million a year. Three clauses, detailed further down, set the terms.

What I recommend. The brand's executive committee gives a pair, one person from finance and one from IT, a month to inventory the vendor contracts and build the agent registry. Then come the rules for agents' access to the brand's site.

The paradox. American Express is building a guarantee for purchases made by agents, while judging the volume of those purchases low.

What's moving. Spotify answers other companies' assistants without handing over its customers' history; 1Password, the password manager, lets an agent log in to an account without ever seeing the password.

Decoded. What each vendor is preparing, why building your agents at the vendor is not enough, and the three clauses to obtain.

The story. Burberry is hiring the engineer who will build its agent platform and the registry that records them; Chanel and Louis Vuitton are also hiring for their agents; Richemont is hiring to get its business partners to adopt an AI manifesto.

Beta Luxury. Walmart publishes the rules every agent entering its site must follow: a page a brand can write for its own site.

Coming next. Estée Lauder Companies' quarterly results on 2 November.

The paradox of the week

American Express is preparing a guarantee for purchases placed by an agent, which it still judges rare.

American Express is preparing for the arrival of shopping agents. On 23 October, presenting its results to financial analysts, Stephen Squeri, the chief executive, described a protection under construction: the group will cover certain purchases by a customer when the registered agent placing them makes a mistake, according to PYMNTS, an American site specializing in payments.

On the same analyst call, Stephen Squeri set a limit. Only approved agents will enter its systems, and only through its official access points: an application programming interface, the door through which one tool queries another, or an MCP connector (Model Context Protocol, the protocol that connects an agent to a company's tools), according to PYMNTS.

"We're not going to allow agents to run rogue through our system," he added, according to Digital Transactions, an American payments magazine.

Yet the market remains small: "It's still early in the game and volumes are still small," the chief executive acknowledges, according to American Banker, the American daily of the banking industry.

“American Express lets in only the shopping agents it has registered.”

I infer that American Express is setting its rules while the volume is low: it is simpler to lay them down before agents arrive in large numbers.

Sources for this section3 links
What's moving

Spotify keeps its customers' listening history, 1Password keeps their passwords.

Spotify chooses the track, and the listening history stays with it. On 22 October, Gustav Söderström, co-chief executive, presented Spotify as the service people should be able to use from any agent, according to the transcript of the analyst call published by Earnings Whispers. Spotify was the first music service connected to Muse, Meta's assistant, and is also connected to ChatGPT and Claude, according to TechCrunch, an American technology news site. The customer's agent asks for a track. Spotify chooses it with its own recommendation systems, and the listening history stays at Spotify. Neither the earnings release nor the transcript gives any usage figure.

1Password fills in the login form itself. On 22 October, 1Password launched a service that lets a personal agent open its user's account on a site: the user approves the request in 1Password, which fills in the form itself; the agent never receives the password, according to TechCrunch and The Next Web. The service is open to Muse and to GrokBot, SpaceXAI's assistant; 13 other assistants are announced, according to 1Password's blog.

For a brand that sells online, a customer's account on its site (orders, wish list, appointments) can therefore be opened by the customer's agent.

Sources for this section6 links
Decoded

What Salesforce, ServiceNow and SAP are preparing, and the three clauses that protect the brand.

In these three announcements, the vendor that hosts the brand's data controls the entry of agents that are not its own; two of them are going to charge for that entry.

What Salesforce is preparing. According to The Information on 22 October, Salesforce will require starting in November that any outside agent, one a brand has built with Anthropic or OpenAI models for instance, be registered before acting in its tools. Each action of that agent will become a billed "interaction," and the customer will keep paying the AI model provider separately. The price has not yet been set, Crypto Briefing, a cryptocurrency news site, confirms on 24 October. New customers will have three months, after prices are announced, to register their agents; existing customers will comply at their renewal.

Salesforce had written this rule as early as September, according to SalesforceBEN, a site specializing in the Salesforce ecosystem. Each successful call by a registered agent, through an application programming interface or an MCP connector, counts as a billed action, paid in Flex Credits, the prepaid credits Salesforce deducts based on usage, with 30 days' notice before the first invoice. Automated connections between tools that are not agents stay at the current rate.

At ServiceNow and SAP, a mandatory checkpoint, counted by usage. ServiceNow, a vendor of tools for managing internal services, presented in May, at its Knowledge 2026 conference, a mandatory checkpoint for outside agents, billed by usage, according to UC Today, a site specializing in workplace tools. Mark Murphy, an analyst at the bank JPMorgan, saw it as a tax on customers who use outside agents, according to PYMNTS.

SAP, the German vendor of finance, purchasing and inventory management tools, requires agents from elsewhere to go through Joule, its own agents, to reach its customers' data, and counts each such use, according to the research firm Forrester. Running Joule agents remains free until 31 December 2026; Forrester sees this as a free period designed to get customers used to it before making them pay.

Christian Klein, SAP's chief executive, nevertheless assured investors in April that customers would not pay to access their own data, according to PYMNTS. The firm Gartner warns that the bill will depend on how SAP defines an "action," reports The Register, a British IT news site.

“An English court has already made an SAP customer pay for its tools' indirect access to the data hosted at SAP.”

The order of magnitude. The price of an action by an agent built outside Salesforce is not published. The price of an action by Agentforce, the agents Salesforce sells itself, is: 20 Flex Credits, or $0.10, according to Salesforce's price list. I apply this price to outside agents, for lack of knowing any other. My assumption: 200 boutiques, 10 appointments prepared per day per boutique, 30 agent actions per appointment, 300 days a year. That makes 18 million actions, or $1.8 million a year; with 10 actions per appointment, $0.6 million. This calculation rests on my assumptions; it gives the scale of the negotiation.

L'Oréal built its agents at Salesforce. L'Oréal runs Agentforce in its consumer care department in North America, for 25 brands, including Lancôme, CeraVe and Kiehl's, and more than 300 advisors; the average handling time of a case has dropped from about 7 minutes to about 2.5 minutes when the advisor does not have to edit the agent's draft, according to the case study published by Salesforce, which sells the tool, and picked up by PYMNTS. According to The Information, the new billing targets customers who have an outside AI do the work rather than Salesforce's own: agents built at the vendor, like L'Oréal's, are not its target.

Why not build everything at the vendor? For a task that stays within a single tool, as at L'Oréal, it is the simplest choice. As soon as an agent reads 2 tools, it is outside one of the two. A client advisor preparing a VIC's appointment needs the client's file, in Salesforce, and the inventory, in SAP. Copying the inventory into Salesforce through an automated connection without an agent, which Salesforce leaves at the current rate, does not settle the case of the agent that must read SAP directly: it remains an outside agent there, and could pay for every action there, depending on the price SAP sets. Building everything at one vendor also makes the brand more dependent on it.

The precedent exists. In February 2017, the High Court of England and Wales ruled that Diageo, the spirits group, owed SAP additional licenses because 2 tools built on Salesforce, one for its sales representatives, the other for its customers, indirectly accessed SAP data, according to The Register.

In The Information's article, Nick Hamm, a consultant, says that most of the companies he advises run Anthropic and OpenAI models inside Salesforce's tools without paying Salesforce anything for it. Some could, in his view, move their data out of the tool if the fees are too high. A Salesforce salesperson wrote to him that customers will also be able to buy unlimited use of agents, through a dedicated license: this flat-rate package exists, and a brand can ask for it.

What I recommend. Edition 23 said it for the agents sold by vendors: the brand chooses its terms when the contract renews. This time, the bill targets the agents the brand builds itself, at a vendor that does not sell them: the method applies to them too. Before the renewal of each vendor contract that hosts customer, sales or product data, the purchasing department obtains three written clauses: - the price of actions: actions by the brand's agents, whatever their provider, are included in the contract price up to a written annual volume; a written definition states what an "action" is; beyond that volume, the price per action is set in advance, under an annual spending cap that nothing exceeds without written agreement; any increase is announced in writing, with notice; - full export of the data, in a format other tools can read, at no cost and within a set time frame: this is the clause that keeps the brand in control of its VICs' records, and that makes the threat of leaving credible; - the list of authorized agents, kept by the brand, is authoritative: the vendor bills only the agents on it, and each invoice details the actions agent by agent.

If the vendor gives up on billing, these clauses cost only the time it takes to negotiate them; if it bills, they set the price before it is imposed. When the contract is signed by the group, its purchasing department negotiates these clauses, at the request of the brand's executive committee.

In one month, the finance and IT pair records the renewal date of each contract, the number of agents touching each tool, and an estimate of their actions per month. The purchasing department then leads the negotiation, starting with the contracts that renew within the next 18 months. Reworked, a site specializing in how work is organized in companies, recommends the same inventory in its guide to this new billing.

Sources for this section12 links
The story of the week

What 4 job postings from Burberry, Chanel, Louis Vuitton and Richemont say.

Burberry is hiring the engineer who will build its agent platform. The posting, published on 23 October on BoF Careers, the job site of The Business of Fashion, describes a tool shared across the whole company. Each team will deploy its agents on it. The tool will keep a registry of all agents, coordinate their work, evaluate their results and set what each one is allowed to read. The posting asks for expérience with Microsoft's online AI services, including Azure OpenAI, or their equivalents at Amazon and Google.

Richemont, owner of Cartier and Van Cleef & Arpels, is setting a framework for its partners. The group is hiring, for six months, in Plan-les-Ouates, near Geneva, a person in charge of getting its business partners to adopt an "AI Manifesto," according to its job posting. I did not find the text of the manifesto online.

2 other postings were published in October. Chanel Parfums Beauté is hiring an intern to prepare its product sheets "for AI agents" (translated from French) (Chanel). Louis Vuitton is hiring an intern to take part in rolling out its "first Retail AI Agent," to support the "front and back of store" teams (translated from French) (Louis Vuitton, LVMH website).

“Burberry's platform will keep the registry of all its agents.”

Burberry's agents will be built on online AI services. If its clients' records and its inventory are hosted at other vendors, these agents will be outside agents there, and will pay for every action the day those vendors follow Salesforce.

The question to ask. If, like Burberry, you build a platform shared by all your teams, ask that its registry count the actions of each agent, tool by tool. I recommended this registry in Edition 21 for security; it will also help you check vendors' invoices.

Sources for this section4 links
Beta Luxury

Walmart's rules page, to rewrite for your brand's site.

Walmart has published the rules every shopping agent entering its site must follow, according to its press release. It makes three elements public: a separate profile for each agent in the customer's account, with a spending cap set by the customer ($50, $100 or $200 in its examples); a gateway, "Agent Gateway," that goes through the MCP protocol; and terms of use written for agents.

The prohibitions are precise, Digital Commerce 360, an American site specializing in e-commerce, details on 23 October: acting beyond the customer's instructions, accessing unauthorized information, receiving a card number, adding or changing a payment method. Agent profiles are announced "in the next month," with no precise date; the gateway is announced in a trial version for companies and developers, with no date for general availability, according to the press release and Retail Dive, an American site specializing in retail.

“Vendors set the entry conditions for the brand's agents in their tools; the brand can set those for its customers' agents on its site.”

The exercise. One page, written by the legal counsel and the head of e-commerce, stating what a customer's agent may do on the brand's site: - through which technical access it connects, and whether it must declare itself as an agent; - what it may read in the customer's account, and what it never sees; - what it may do alone (book an appointment, track an order) and what requires the customer's consent; - the faults for which the brand blocks it.

The brand gains a piece of information: in a VIC's account, it knows what the VIC bought personally and what their agent bought. Today, Walmart acknowledges, the agent logs in with the customer's credentials, and their purchases get mixed together. It takes a month: the legal counsel and the head of e-commerce write the page; the technical team checks that the site can recognize an agent and apply these rules to it, before opening the site to agents.

Sources for this section3 links
In my reading list

The Information, the Financial Times and The New York Times, to dig deeper.

Coming next

The agentic Luxury calendar, 29 October to 5 November.

  1. Monday 2 November, 8:30 a.m. in New York.

    Results for the first quarter of fiscal 2027 of Estée Lauder Companies, owner of Tom Ford Beauty, Le Labo and La Mer, according to the group's press release, picked up by the stock market news site Finviz. Broadcast live on the group's website. To listen for: the share of AI tools and agents in expenses, if the group puts a figure on it.

A Luxury brand has always negotiated its locations, its rents, its distribution commissions. The agents' double bill joins that list. The registry of its agents, with the count of their actions, will help it negotiate that bill. A Luxury brand leaves it to no one else to set the price of what belongs to it, its data included. Luxe oblige!

Sources for this section2 links

LUXE ÆTERNAI newsletter

Get the next edition

Every Thursday at 8:30am, what AI agents change, or don't, for luxury Maisons. You subscribe on LinkedIn, in one click.

Michaël Tsakiris
Paris, Thursday